QUOTE(mrxak @ Mar 11 2005, 05:01 PM)
They are social constructs for the purpose of "eliteness" and exclusion. They are irrelevant, disruptive, and annoying (heck, they're disturbing the peace as I type this). And yet they exist.
Rather than me explaining to you why I despise them (as if these trivial things weren't reason enough for me), why don't you explain why I shouldn't? What hidden positives do us poor non-fraternity people miss out on? I've certainly seen plenty of overt "positives", but what is the big important reason for them to exist?
Let's face it, even without personal experience to back it up, you people have major public relations issues. Use this opportunity to share with us all the good side of your little groups.
[snapback]1394104[/snapback]
The number one thing about it is that you can't explain it to someone who hasn't experienced it. Sometimes people will understand part of the brotherhood you experience if they went to an all boys school, but that's pretty much the only experience I know of that is even vaguely similar.
While I don't think I can ever capture everything about what it means to be in my fraternity, I'll just go through some basic ones that people sometimes don't even realize. While everything I say is most specific to my school, I know that it often holds true across the board.
Greeks perform more community service than GDI's. Often a Greek organization will choose one specific charity to throw most of its weight behind. Greeks at my school raise thousands of dollars and donate thousands of hours of service to these worthy causes. Some charities supported at my school are nationwide cancer organization, abuse and domestic violence, etc. For example, next week my fraternity is putting on its annual Pledge Queen Pageant, which sorority pledges from each sorority enter in for a chance to enter Miss Arkansas. We raise thousands of dollars from ticket prices which we donate to our charity. Each member is required to do, on average at my school, almost 10 hours of community service per semester. Do you think very many GDI's hold themselves to that standard?
Greeks almost always have a higher GPA average than non Greeks. The Greek womens average is 3.1ish, mens is 3.0ish, and GDI's is around 2.75. We have academic standards that don't allow you to be initiated and/or impose study hall requirements for not making grades. We also often have older members tutor younger members in subjects they've already had. We also keep resources that members compile, such as study guides, old tests, quizzes, etc. This helps our members to achieve higher grades than would be possible without the support of the fraternity.
Greeks are more productive when they go out into the world, both in the business world and the community. You will find that many Greeks are important members of their church, local businesses, and local government. It is because of the experiences you have, the opportunities to learn and grow, that Greeks become more rounded people, and through that more successful.
Don't get me wrong, there are idiots in every fraternity and sorority, just like their are idiots that aren't in fraternities and sororities. We probably do drink more, we probably do cause more problems on a college campus than the GDI's. But what it really comes down to is that we just plain do more all around. You just see the bad things.
It's funny that you ask me to explain, because one of the primary foci of Greek life nationwide is to do a better job publicizing the positive actions of their organizations.
Oh, and they are definitely not constructs for the purpose of eliteness and exclusion. Greek life looks for people who have potential in their life to excel in some capacity, and actively recruits those people...especially total package people.
Also, every Greek organization has meanings, principles, ideals, etc. While some of these are secret, there are plenty of open mottos that show what that organization tries to achieve within its members. Not every Greek ever attains those ideals, and some organizations aren't as focused on it as others, but at least we don't just sit on the sideline and bitch about it.
You hit on an important point yourself....if these organizations weren't a successful model, they would have folded long ago. It got bad in the 80s and 90s, and Greek numbers were going down nationwide, but Greek life is no longer in decline and is showing positive growth every year now. It was out of control, but the corrective curve is coming back.
Everything that I hit on is important, but to me its just the numbers that don't reflect the heart of the issue. I share closer bonds with some (not all) of my fraternity brothers than people who I thought were my very best friends. And don't do me the injustice of suggesting to yourself that its because we were hazed together, or because we were forced to drink together, or any other stupid ideas like that. The fraternity's education program for new members and their bigs creates relationships that will never be forgotten.